World views of Dr. L. Allan Austin

Recylcling Pallets
August 11, 2011

‘Tis the season to be shopping and we are shopping! National Public Radio (NPR) says that Black Friday and Cyber Monday both exceeded anticipated holiday sales levels. This year, according to the National Retail Federation, holiday sales are expected to ring in at $447.1 billion; that’s about $1,450 per capita. With holiday sales representing about 20 percent of total annual retail sales, discounters, department stores, grocery outlets, and specialty shops make sure to stock sufficient merchandise for us to choose from. And, for those of us who don’t like to elbow our way through the shopping mall, we can always order on-line. E-commerce sales (which are not included in the above forecasted number) are expected to reach $32.4 billion- a whopping 11 percent increase over last year.

So, how does all the merchandise we purchase during the holidays find its way from factories to warehouses and from warehouses to store shelves and ultimately to us? Business consultants refer to this process as Supply Chain Management (SCM). To give you an idea of the importance of SCM, the US Military and Wal-Mart invest heavily in this process and are considered to be leading experts in the field. SCM makes sure goods are where they need to be when they need to be there. Despite the complexities of SCM, at the bottom of it all and critical to the movement of most goods is the simple pallet.

pallet is a portable platform used for handling and transporting goods. While a pallet can be used to hold or transport a single item, it is normally used to handle what SCM Pallet load with Text for Recygal copyprofessionals’ term, a unit load. A typical unit load consists of goods packed in corrugated cardboard cartons stacked on a pallet and wrapped in plastic wrap for stability. The importance of the unit load cannot be underestimated; with over 1.2 billion pallets in circulation in the USA, 93 percent of all goods move on pallets (Beverage & Diamond, 2009).

Over 90 percent of all pallets are made of wood or wood-based composites. Approximately, 40 percent of all the hardwood lumber (especially low grade lumber) produced annually in the USA is used for pallet manufacturing- making pallets the largest single user of USA produced hardwood lumber. But, before we accuse the wooden pallet of being the primary cause of USA deforestation, we must take a look at current USA lumber statistics, forestry practices, government regulations, and pallet recycling activities.

Although over 400 million new wooden pallets are produced annually (Buelmann 2008), this past decade has seen a 25 percent reduction in the production of USA hardwood lumber. This table shows the changes in the production of hardwood lumber in millions of board feet:

Changes in USA Hardwood Lumber Production Recygal

So, with such high pallet demand, why has hardwood lumber production experienced such a decline? Simply put, pallet manufacturing was not always the leading user of hardwood lumber; it is only because the global economy has pushed the production of other high demand wooden products overseas that the pallet now holds the position of Número Uno. Because furniture, flooring, cabinets and many other hardwood products can be produced much less expensively in Asia than in the USA, these finished goods are now imported to the USA rather than manufactured here. And, contrary to popular belief, most of these items are not made from USA sourced hardwood lumber. To nail USA hardwood lumber even harder, a slowdown in new construction starts has also weakened the domestic hardwood lumber market. With so many other hardwood lumber products being made overseas, why is USA pallet manufacturing surviving? To remain cost competitive in the world of transportation and storage, pallets are made from low grade hardwood lumber (lumber often not feasible for other uses) and must be made locally so the cost to transport the empty pallets to where they are needed is minimal.

Wood, whether low or high grade, is a sustainable resource. So, how do we make sure our forests are sustained? In North America, wooden product manufacturers (including pallet makers) can source wood certified under theSustainable Forest Initiative (SFI). Some manufacturers not only source such wood, but participate in the certification program themselves. SFI certified companies, at their discretion, can display the Certified Sustainable Forest Initiative Logo on their products. Because manufacturers do not have to be part of the program to source SFI certified wood, wood products that are available in the market place without the SFI Logo (including pallets) may actually have been manufactured from SFI sourced wood. With the greening of corporate America, many corporations are implementing Supply Chain Management practices that require the use of SFI certified wood in their pallet programs. As corporations use these programs to increase public awareness of their greening environmental practices, the more likely we will begin to see pallets stamped with a SFI logo in the future.

Although a pallet may be made from sustainable-sourced wood, it will not last forever. Surprisingly, the average useful lifetime of a wooden pallet is only 7 trips. So, what happens to these out of commission pallets? Many local and state governments have enacted laws that ban the disposal of pallets in landfills. According to an article posted on the website,Pallet Enterprise, over 33 percent of municipal landfills reject pallet waste and only 1 percent of obsolete pallets end up in landfills. (Mosqueda, 2010). The vast majority of pallets are not landfilled, they are refurbished and repurposed.

Refurbishing helps to extend pallet longevity and enables pallets to remain longer in circulation. But, to refurbish pallets, damaged pallets must first be collected. It is estimated that USA pallet recyclers reclaim more than 460 million pallets annually. This reclamation figure is slightly higher than the estimated 430 – 450 million new pallets manufactured each year. Large national poolers such as CHEP issue, collect and distribute pallets where and when they are needed. Issuing over 300 million pallets a year, the businesses practices of companies like CHEP can greatly influence the environmental impact of pallets within our country. When handling such a large amount of pallets, collecting damaged pallets is just part of the process. With an on-going source of damaged pallets, refurbishing helps to lessen the demand for new pallets; less demand for new pallets is less demand for hardwood.

Repurposing decommissioned pallets helps to extend the useful life of the hardwood material. Deconstructing the pallet and using the lumber to make down-cycled goods such as backyard compost bins, garden fencing, and ornamental signage enable pallet wood to become useful items for the home. Even badly damaged pallet lumber can be chipped and ground to make garden mulch and animal bedding.

So, next time you go shopping think of all those pallets that have helped to bring the merchandise to you. And, next time you mulch your garden, it is possible that you may be adding bedding to your flowers that once transported flowers to the nursery! Now that’s recycling that goes naturally back to the earth!

Recycle-Wreath-with-Recygal

Happy Holiday Shopping!

© 2010 Recycle Life, LLC
RecyGalTM logo and the RecyGal TMcharacter are registered trademarks and registered copyrights of Recycle Life , LLC

References:References: “Holiday Shopping off to an Encouraging Start, Assoc. Press, November 26, 2010, “Cyber Monday Sales Top $1 Billion for First Time”, December 1, 2010, National Public Radio, www.npr.com, “NFR Forecasts Holiday Sales Increase Of 2.3 Percent”, K. Grannis, October 6, 2010, www.nrf.com , “U.S. Population 2010: 308 Million and Growing”, R. Schlesinger, December 30, 2009, www.politics.usnews.com, “2010 Holiday Survival Kit”, NFR, www.nrf.com/holidays, “comScore Forecasts 11 Percent Growth for 2010 Holiday E-Commerce Spending”, A. Lipsman, November 23, 2010, www.comscore.com, “Supply Chain Management”, www.rockfordconsulting.com, “How Do Differing Standards Increase Trade Costs? The Case of Pallets”, G. Raballand, E. Aldaz-Carroll, The World Economy, Vol. 30, Issue 4, p. 685-702, April 2007, “Perspectives on Material Handling from the United States”, Presentation at INTERMATEX 93, R.E. Ward, Materials Handling Industry of America, Charlotte, NC, www.MHIA.org, “Plastic or Wood? Packaging Wars Break Out at APHIS”, Beverage & Diamond, P.C. September 15, 2009, www.bdlaw.com, “It’s a Small World after All”- Will Global Standards Impact Local Markets?”, C. Brindley, 2002, www.palletenterprise.com, “News, Pallets Move the World”, www.greenlightpallet.com, “Pallet Recycling”, www.benefits-of-recycling.com, “Pallets Move The World, The Case for Developing System-Based Designs for Unit Loads”, M. White & P. Hammer, Forest Products Journal, Vol. 55, No. 3, March 2005, “How green are your pallets?”, S. Lacefield, www.develocity.com, “Supply Chains and the Army”, Knowledge@Wharton, Special to CNE, News.com, December 6, 2003, www.news.cnet.com, “Changes in the Hardwood Lumber Industry and Their Impacts on the Pallet Industry”, E. Brindley, February 1, 2010, www.palletenterprise.com, “Identifying Impact Factors on Successful Exporting of the United States Hardwood Industries to Mexico, Asia, and Europe”, O. Parhizkar, Dissertation for PhD in Forest and Forestry Products, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA, March 21, 2008, “Comparison of important competitiveness factors for small-to medium-sized forest enterprises”, O. Parhizkar, et. al., Forest Products Journal, May 2009, “How Green Are Your Pallets? A Closer Look at Sustainability and the Pallet Industry”, www.palletenterprise.com, A. Mosqueda, September 1, 2010, “Plastic Pallets Gain Ground In an Eco-Conscious World”, www.ptonline.com, J. Grande, 2008, “Ban on landfilling of wooden pallets in North Carolina: an assessment of recycling and industry capacity,” Department of Wood Science and Forest Products, Virginia Tech, Books Froest Products Center, Blacksburg, VA, U.Buehlmann, et al. June 6, 2008.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*